Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Reservation Telecommunication
Initiative
  • 2006 Governor’s Rural Development Conference
  • August 18, 2006


  • Ron S. Lee, Native Policy Group, LLC
2
Telecommunication Challenges
on Indian Lands
  • Status


  • Programs


  • Barriers


  • Recommendations






  • Challenges to Assessing & Improving Telecommunications for Native Americans on Tribal Lands
  • General Accounting Office, Jan 2006
  • http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d06189.pdf
3
Status

  • Telephone Subscribers – Only 68% of households on Tribal lands
    • Navajo Nation’s Telephony Infrastructure

  • Internet Subscribers – Although data is largely unknown, FCC estimates that broadband penetration on Indian lands is less than 10%



  • 2000 US Census
4
Programs
  • USDA Rural Utility Service (RUS)


  • Federal Communication Commission
    • Discounts on cost of telephone service
    • Financial incentives to encourage wireless providers
    • E-Rate Funding


  • National Telecommunication Information Administration (NTIA)
5
Barriers
  • Rights-of-way (ROW) issues
    • Leasing fees


  • Jurisdictional Issues (State & Tribes)


  • Lack of Capitol for Infrastructure Development
    • No Incentives for Private Investors


  • Geographical Location – Rural & Rugged Terrain, Remoteness, low population density


  • Lack of access to training technicians, technical assistance and planning resources
6
GAO’s Recommendations
  • Congress should direct FCC
      • To determine what data is needed
      • How to collect the data
      • Report back to Congress its findings


  • Congress should also consider amending the Communications Act regarding the Universal Service Funds
      • Library eligibility on tribal lands
7
What Tribes Are Doing
  • Developing own telecom systems


  • Developing wireless technologies


  • Providing technical training for members


  • Developing decision-making process to address rights-of-way
8
What Can Congress Do?
  • Telecommunication Reauthorization
    • Act needs to recognize tribal authority
    • Rural funds directly to tribal lands


  • Mandate Census Bureau to collect internet subscriber data in 2010


  • Modify federal eligibility criteria so that tribal libraries can receive E-rate funds
9
What Can Arizona Do?
  • Amend A.R.S. 42-5029 to include tribal governments in state shared revenue to provide permanent funds for telecommunication infrastructure


  • Develop Other Policy Objectives
    • Joint Power Agreement (ACC/NNTRC)


  • Assist tribes in seeking permanent federal funds to pay for telecommunication infrastructure
10
Transaction Privilege Tax (TPT)
  • Arizona’s version of a sales tax


  • Represents approximately 51% of General Fund Revenues in FY’04


  • Shared among State, County and Cities through a distribution base
      • 25% to cities in proportion to their population
      • 40.51% to counties according to a formula
      • Remaining 34.49% is retained by state
11
Tribal TPT Contributions
  • Contributions Between FY’01-’04
    • $93.6 Mil Collected on AZ Indian Reservations
      • $23.4 Mil average per year
      • 42.0% Increase within 4 years
      • 33.2% Mil in FY’08


    • $58.6 Mil Collected on Navajo Nation (62.3%)
      • $14.7 Mil average per year
      • 47.4% Increase within 4 years
      • $21.7 Mil in FY’08

12
Legislative Activities

  • Jan-May: HB 2689 – Study Committee
  • Jun-Nov: Conduct Hearings/Meetings
  • Dec 31st: Submit Report (6-30-07)


  • Jan-May ’07: Introduce Tribal Telecom Bill that Incorporates TPT
  • Jan-May ’08: 2nd Option or Attempt
13
Study Committee’s Objective
  • ID Methods to Track TPT Contributions Made by Tribes


  • ID Distribution Formula


  • ID TPT Distribution for Tribes


  • Recommend Tribal Telecommunication Legislation that Incorporates TPT
14
Partnerships
  • AZ Telecommunications & Information Council (ATIC)


  • Government Information Technology Agency (GITA)


  • Greater Arizona Development Authority (GADA)


  • Other
15
Tribal Telecom Coalition
16
Ad Hoc Meeting on 6-6-06
  • Need tribal consensus on TPT usage
  • Form a telecommunication coalition
  • Meet with Governor
  • Educate tribes, municipalities and counties
  • Raise awareness for legislative support
17
Next Steps
  • Community awareness & support


  • Educate legislators and local governments


  • Get politically active in state and local government affairs
18
Contacts
  • Navajo Nation Telecommunication Regulatory Commission
    • Ernest Franklin, Executive Director
      • PO Box 900
      • Window Rock, AZ 86515
      • Phone: (928) 871-7854
      • Fax: (928) 871-7856
      • Email: efranklin@nntrc.org or www:nntrc.org


  • Navajo Nation Communications & Utilities Department
    • Pearl Lee, Program Manager
      • PO Box 2928
      • Window Rock, AZ 86515
      • Phone: (928) 871-7740
      • Fax: (928) 871-7741
      • Email: p.lee@citlink.net


  • Native Policy Group, LLC
    • Ron Lee, President
      • 2434 W. Knowles Ave
      • Mesa, AZ 85202
      • Phone: (602) 319-4419
      • Email: ron.lee@nativepolicygroup.com